STUN NIGHT

Well another amazing night!! I was very entertained...VERY!

Here is my take....

James...first song REALLY good, but not nearly as orbital as the judges had it. Second...ORBITAL....It was really good. Even though I too heard when he was off here and there, it didn't really matter. I think for me I LIKE him as a person the best for some reason. Soooo likeable. But I don't know if he is the American Idol for me.


Jacob....first song while sang well, WAY too weird for him. Too much of a different feel. Agreed with Randy. He actually had a mild hand to crotch thing going like some of those guys do. It was a big NOOOOOO in my book. However his second song was actually really good. He sang it well. One of his best. I still think he should go next though.

Scotty.....what is there to say. The guy is orbital. I LOVE LOVE LOVE his voice. Sooo good. Sooo sexy (his voice, not him, he is a newborn) Sooo entertaining. He is the american idol to me.

Lauren.....first song was good, but nothing great in my opinion. She is NOT Carrie and paled in comparison to how she does that song. And the second was butchered literally in my opinion. Some of the notes and places she did REALLY REALLY well, and others she almost ruined. She DID NOT connect with the song. Notice how Scotty is always telling the story of what he is singing, and she rarely if ever does. She did LOOK like a complete STUN tonight in both of her performances. A COMPLETE STUN!! Sooo pretty.

Haley....first song...I felt like the judges were weird on it. I actually kind of liked it. And the second was literally spinning in orbit. She did it REALLY REALLY well and I full on loved it.

Soooo, my opinion is IF they do bottom 3 (which they didn't last week) it woud be Jacob, Lauren and Haley...with the one going home....Jacob. SURELY it is finally over for him. I think on just this night though (not overall) the lineup for me of who entertained me best would be....
1. Scotty
2. Haley (I know ~ shocker!)
3. James
4. Jacob
5. Lauren

So best of the night, again was Scotty. And going home...Jacob