Haley cooked herself.

Well, Haley took a wild, bloody bite out of the hand that's been feeding her. She's going home. Bottom line, her first song sucked. Not only was the song choice bad, she just didn't sing it that well. She was definitely screaming at the end. Her second song was awesome. In fact, it could have redeemed her. But her indignant, annoying attitude is what slammed the nail in the coffin. Was she dead serious? I wanted to smack her. Quit arguing, rolling your eyes, and making borderline sarcastic comments. It is not going to go over well with America. I also didn't like the way the judges handled it.. have some back bone and stick to what you're saying. "Sorry we were so hard on you.." Really? Ridiculous. It's moments like that where I miss Simon the most. He would have wiped that annoying look right off her face with just the right scathing quip. And them having to give her a standing ovation and act like she was the greatest performer of all time on her second one was mildly repulsive.

So how was that?? And you KNOW I've been a huge Haley fan from day one. If she lost me for a fan, I have a feeling she lost countless others as well.

Scotty's song choice on his first one was so perfect I almost couldn't stand it. LOVED it. I didn't love his second one, but it doesn't matter. That's how good his first one was.

James really redeemed himself tonight. Liked both of his performances.

I also really liked Lauren's performances, but she hasn't WOW'ed me in awhile. She needs to step it up.

As for Lady Gaga... I have such mixed feelings about her. I love her songs, I must admit. I listened to her first CD exclusively for months on end. However, I find her constant political messages annoying (She is extremely liberal and loud)... Not just because I disagree with her, but because she's a pop star, not a politician. Plus, she's just not smart. Stick to singing Bad Romance and Poker Face and shut up. I really don't care one way or another about her crazy, freak costumes. It doesn't shock me at all anymore. I agree she was way too much for Scotty and James, lol. The rest of her advice was ok, and really not any worse than any of the other "mentors" they have. Personally, 98% of the time the mentors are pointless anyway. At least Lady Gaga was somewhat entertaining.

Final prediction - Haley cooked herself and will be sent galloping home with a swift kick.