fantasia...the big suckfest

i feel bad that american idol has to admit that fantasia actually won a season of american idol...along with taylor hicks, ruben studdard and im gonna say it...kris allen...

good riddens on miley and bob marley...buh bye.

lauren needs to stop being a little cry baby...its american idol...everyones gonna leave at one point...theres only one winner...however, her fall down the stairs was quite possibly the best part of the show....i rewound to amuse myself....

Mel's judgements

I love Elton John, so naturally I loved the night. As Mike pointed out, they should have paid Elton however many millions he wanted and let him play the piano for everyone... imagine how good that would have been?? Maybe he'll stop by for tomorrows show... Anyway, my judgements: Scotty: Winner. Of the whole show. Love him. Naima, aka Africa: Craptastic. I don't like her feel at all. A joke. Pia: Love, love, love her voice. So much, that I can almost look beyond her somewhat boring performances. She's got to kick it up a notch, but her voice will carry her almost to the end, and possibly to the final two. Paul: Yawn. Kind of repulsive. Matter of time before he's packing his bags. Lauren: Great voice, liked it. I was actually kind of nervous for her with that song, and thought she pulled it off well. Thia Megia: Bye bye! Casey: Loved it! Jacob Lusk: Goober. Probably won't go home tomorrow, but he's a ticking time bomb. Stefano: I don't really know why, but I've decided I hate him. There's something repulsive about him. He has a nice little voice, but in my opinion he butchered that song. None of them are Elton John, but that just paled in comparison to the original and left me wondering how he's made it this far. Another ticking time bomb, and I wouldn't be the least bit sad to see him ejected tomorrow. Haley: Liked it. I don't know if I'd get on the judges bandwagon of "best performance of the night"... easy. But it was good, her voice is very unique, and I still like her. She just bought herself another week. James: Loved it. Very fun performance, highly entertaining. Judges: Seriously, kick it up a notch. I need a scathing comment, or at least a harsh critique. Their critiques are few and far between, and always followed by ten compliments. Come on, give me something here. Bottom 3 predictions - Paul or Stefano, Thia, and Naima... with Thia and Naima packing.

in my opinion...

my thoughts on this season so far. as i do have to point out ive only seen bits and pieces of the other shows so im probably going to annoy a few of u who have been watching since the beginning...theres nothing worse than having someone jump in halfway through the show calling things as they see it, but....HERE I AM!!! scotty-loved it. love his feel, and love his voice. have decided even if he goes out now we will prob still hear his song on country radio. weird reggae, dreadlock wannabe-crap. crap. crap. was wondering what her feel even was? and how she even made it into the top 11? NOT into the song, the reggae, her hair, or her...nope. stepheNO-boring. i wanted to fast forward my dvr to the next person...tiny dancer? really? your gonna pick that song, which im sorry, is a song where it should be HARD for u to not stick out, and make me wanna listen bc i love it, and i was just bored.... asian miley cyrus wannabe- poop...sounded nasaly, and just meh....too young. needs to go lauren- liked it...was into it, loved the song choice, and her....probably wont win, but thought she was cute, and liked her voice. dress choice? no.,..reminded me of ursula from little mermaid james- was def into it...if you can entertain me, im in...and i was def entertained...kinda all over the place and actually wasnt really even paying too much attention to his voice but i was lovin every minute of it. (mom-doesnt he look like kevin hynes? rob and ants friend???) pia- obviously her voice is a stun, there was no question about that, song choice was great too, but next american idol? im thinkin no. growling benny and the jets girl- i was into it...LOVE that elton song, could be my fav. thought she sang it well too, however phil and i both got a few chuckles on the way she moved around the stage, real gangly and doofus like...def not a great performer. compton man- im sorry, but..... IS AMERICAN IDOL DEAD SERIOUS?!?!?! I couldnt help but go from scared to histerics....phil of course wanted to immediatly fast forward...do i think he has a good voice? sure. is it bizzare as crap? most defintely. not only was i not into his voice, i really wasnt into him...or they way he performed...his eyes were shut the whole performance... whisper, bradly cooper(but not as funny, or good looking) look alike, boy- hated it...my worst performance of the night...found myself wondering how he was in the top 11 as well??? and i literally have no words for his outfit....none. casey-STUN. my fav of the night...loved every moment of it. love him, his voice, and his attitude...and the song was perf for him my bottom 3: stehpaNO...miley cyrus...and bob marley wannabe thank u and goodnight.

A GOOD SHOW....

This will be quick (I think) as I am tired, but I like to do this when it is fresh on my mind...I thought the whole show was VERY entertaining again. I love Elton John's music (who doesn't) so that was good right off. They ALL did really good, and some of them did better than I have ever heard them do, ala Haley and even Thia....But as usual my top choice of the night was Scotty. I LOVE his voice. I like the way he acts. He is just REALLY good in my humble opinion, and thoroughly entertains me. Then I had several others that I almost can't even put in an order....Pia, Casey, Jacob, James, and Stefano. They are ALL stuns....and as I look back on this list, it is probably my order for them as well. I did not like Paul tonight. I am over him...he bugs me in almost every way. Naima is a GIANT NOOOO for me. Just don't like her "thing"....Thia though tonight was the best I have ever heard her do, it just wasn't good enough and she should be going for sure. I am also VERY over Lauren. She "sounded" good tonight, but personally I don't think she connected with her song (I have NEVER seen her connect) and I thought she had silly grins going where she shouldn't have. She is just too young, and will probably eventually be a stun, but she is just not there in my book. Haley was surprising good tonight. I think it was because the song sooo suited her growling way of singing. She did it VERY well....but I am telling you that is all she's got. Here are my bottom 3.....Thia, Paul and Naima....though Lauren or Stefano in there would not surprise me either....going home?? Thia and Naima...my order for how I see them is on the side here... ; )

My judgements (read the comment)

Current (2011) Hip Chart - Steven Tyler's nose dive

Apologize...

To John, I see now that you in fact have watched and commented on peoples performances. Although, it was in a weird "my comments" thing so it was hard to see. Still, my apologies.